From “Creating Self-Awareness of Learning that Occurs in Community” by Susan Imel and David Stein, this is the definition of social capital:
Social capital, according to Niemela (2003), is the ability of citizens to cooperate, to use resources, to create networks, to become engaged with each other, and to take responsibility for issues affecting the community. The degree to which individuals engage with the issues is the degree to which social capital increases. Social capital includes the knowledge and networking resources that reside in and are available for a community to use toward the common good. Social capital becomes an outcome of learning as well as a resource to enhance learning. The development of social capital, however, is often unrecognized as an important aspect of informal learning and is overshadowed perhaps by the content inherent in a learning encounter.
Niemela (2003) suggests that informal/non-formal learning can encourage and support social capital through the knowledge that is passed regarding community organization and norms, and stories. The importance of interactions as the way to promote social capital is a predominate aspect of this type of learning (Balatti & Falk, 2002; Falk & Kirkpatrick, 2000; Niemela, 2003).
I very much agree with Imel and Stein that the development of social capital is often unrecognized as an important aspect of informal learning and is overshadowed by an emphasis on content, mainly because of traditional modes of education delivery that put students in the role of passive learners, “sponges” to soak up knowledge.
Now, increasingly, more active learning is valued and seen as a desired outcome of education. It seems that online education at the college level (which is all I've experienced so far) is taking this to heart in the form of discussion boards, chat rooms, and even blog assignments like this. As an online student, I would say that at least 70% of my learning of the course concepts is taking place through reading other students’ postings and responding to them, and participating in the group assignments where we are expected to engage with the readings and put ideas in the readings into practice.
Certainly, in an online community, there is great potential to develop a lot of social capital. Popular social networking sites such as Facebook and Myspace demonstrate that millions of people (including me) invest a lot of time into building social capital with others on these sites. It has certainly contributed to my feeling more connected with people, especially those geographically far away, as well as to my awareness of the development of issues I care about. I have even become more engaged in community issues and activism because of links and announcements posted by others— that engagement includes attending local fundraising events/meetings, writing to contribute to email campaigns, signing petitions, and commenting on blogs. And a big reason I have this deeper level of engagement is because I have a previously established foundation of deep social capital-building in a real face to face milieu—campus groups, clubs, and classes I was involved in as a high school student, undergraduate, and graduate student and as a young teacher/professor.
I am struck by how Imel and Stein discuss that a group like BREAD, a collective of 42 religious organizations in Columbus, Ohio, successfully advocated for better public transportation, tutoring services, and affordable housing for needy communities. These accomplishments are based on “networking among community groups, research of best practices in other communities, and study of local issues, rather than formal education sessions.” In other words, people interacting with people not just like themselves, trusting each other, bonded together by local concerns. To me, this is the ultimate goal of education—I want my participation as an educator to introduce and encourage the value and pleasure of becoming more deeply engaged in one's own communities, and try to make them better places for everyone, not just an elite group.
I want to bring this “deeper” level of engagement and social capital to my online community college classes, when I do create and teach them. And I can’t help feeling that, as in my face to face courses, the students won’t get beyond a superficial level of engagement and social capital-building unless there is a really compelling issue that they have experienced and engaged with outside of just reading or watching something about it. In my face to face classes, I incorporate field trips, group work where they meet outside the classroom to work together, out-of-classroom speakers/events, during which a lot of community bonding and learning occurs not in the “formal” moments of learning, but in the informal/non-formal moments (e.g. the carpool ride to the venue, taking a coffee or meal break together during the group work, conversing with fellow volunteers for a community effort). How can these informal/non-formal learning moments take place in an online-only class? I sense there is a way, and I’d like to learn more from other experienced online teachers of how that has happened for their students.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

Wow Karen, I really enjoyed reading your blog. You discuss so many great ideas! It's so true that we can become involved in many different issues because of the information available online. There's an incredible amount of information about any topic we can dream of! When you were writing about how to incorporate some of the field trip and community activities into your course, I realized I had never thought about that. I too had included activities outside the classroom for my students when I taught years ago. Even though students may be in different communities, I suppose we could still assign certain types of field trips or community activities and then the student could find something in their own community to address the assignment. It might be interesting and even bring a new level of varied cultural insight to the project due to students living in different places and sharing those experiences with the class or group. You really made me think and consider an aspect of online teaching I hadn't thought of before. Teri
ReplyDeleteI have had a similar experience with the maority of line classes I have taken. The best ones, regardless of topic, were those where the instructor lead with a gentle hand, and other than keeping the class from getting too far off track, allowed the experience to become student driven. I think this is where we all need to be, no matter what forum we teach in. You need enough control so that neccessary material is introduced and the class doesn't get out of hand, but be more of a facilitator of the students learning instead of just being the presenter of facts.
ReplyDeleteFirst, kudos on the Halloween vibe (if that's what you're going for!)
ReplyDeleteSecond, I think your point about Facebook is a really important one. I too tend to get more involved in my community through activism and discourse through links that others post as well. As for your question about how informal moments can happen in an online only class, I think that the students might have to take the initiative to get to learn about each other by clicking on someone's profile and initiating a conversations. As an instructor, I'm not sure how to facilitate that, but it seems that those conversations will naturally come one way or another.